Ravenous

A decade of silence ends when you graduate high school and move to Hollowbrook to reunite with your mother and sister. That's the setup; whatever kept the family apart for ten years is still buried under the town's picturesque surface, and something in the shadows suggests it stayed buried for a reason.

Your sister Erica becomes the guide through this reunion, helping you meet the town's residents and dig into questions about your own past as much as the town's secrets. The story moves forward on its own terms, letting the reunion, the mystery, and the household relationships unfold scene by scene rather than through choices you steer.

The horror stays under the surface for most of it, closer to unease than jump scares, which fits a story more interested in what happened to this family than in what's chasing them now.