Aura of Sin

A fresh start in a new town turns out to mean something very different once you notice every neighbor is a succubus, a vampire, or a pixie with an agenda, and all of them have decided you're the new attraction in the area. Losing your old job apparently worked out fine.

Your buddy talked you into the move without mentioning the local population, so the setup here is less "start over" and more "figure out what these women actually want from you." That's about as much plot as the town gives you before it gets down to business.

Play consists of getting to know a rotating cast of supernatural residents through dating-sim style choices, building up individual relationships until they lead somewhere physical. It's a fairly standard visual novel loop, but the pool of love interests is more monstrous than usual.